Special Report

Myanmar discoveries set record straight on glazed ceramics
By Dr Sein Tu

MYANMAR has a long and rich tradition of glazed ceramics that has tended to be overlooked by international scientists. This has been despite scholarly treatises published by eminent Myanmar experts such as U Taw Sein Ko and Dr Than Tun and the writings of a few foreign specialists such as John Guy, who wrote in Ceramic Traditions of South East Asia (published in 1989 by Oxford University Press) that Myanmar was "not traditionally associated with glazed ceramic production and yet there is evidence, both archeological and textual, of a tradition existing in Burma (Myanmar) from at least the ninth century." Art historians of Southeast Asian ceramics have largely ignored Myanmar, which was by default relegated to the status of a mere recipient of ceramic ware originating in China, India and Thailand.  However, historical references to Myanmar glazed ceramics can be traced to impeccable foreign sources, including the Man Shu, a chronicle published during China’s Tang Dynasty (618-907). A reference to Srikshetra, near present-day Pyay, which was the capital of the Pyu kingdom between the third and seventh centuries AD, records that it was surrounded by a circular wall "built of greenish glazed tiles" and that its people engaged in the barter of earthenware as well as glazed ware. Stadtner in his 1999 book The Art of Burma: New Studies records that more than 1000 tin opicified (made more beautiful by making them opaque) lead glazed plaques were inlaid at the Shwegugyi pagoda complex in 1476 by King Dhammaceti (1472-92). The complex is at present-day Innwa, Tada-U Township, Kyaukse District, Mandalay Division Similarly Frazer-Lu in her 1994 book Burmese Crafts: Past and Present (Oxford University Press) noted that the 18th century Kadothein Shrine in Laung-gyet District, Mrauk-U Township, Sittwe District, Rakhine State, was paved with brown, blue and glazed tiles.  The British envoy Henry Yule in his1858 publication, A Narrative of the Mission sent by the Governor-General of India to the Court of Ava in 1855, noted the glazed sandstone decoration on the basement of the Mahatuhlut Bonkyaw Monastery, in Amarapura Township, Mandalay District, Mandalay Division. In addition to the historical records mentioned above, compelling archaeological evidence in the form of religious edifices that are still standing, every one of them with lithic inscriptions recording their date of construction, provide evidence of ancient Myanmar glazed ceramic ware. Among these, prominent examples are selected and presented below: The 9th century Ngakwenadaung pagoda at Bagan whose upper parts are inlaid and decorated by glazed bricks can still be viewed today. Glazed plaques were also discovered in the 10th century Kyaikpun Pagoda near Bago, as recorded by R.C. Temple in his 1894 work, Notes on Antiquities in Rammannadesa (The Talaing Country of Burma.) Descriptions of 22 religious edifices at Bagan dating from the 10th to the 13th centuries, referred to the use of glazed bricks, plaques and tiles, indicating that Myanmar craftsmen had mastered the art of applying glazing, not only to earthenware but to sandstone and metal surfaces as well. A glazed earthenware pot was also found at Bagan in the relic chamber of a stupa built by King Anawrahta (1044-1077), the founder of the first Myanmar empire. Four other 17th century religious edifices in Bagan also have glazed decorations. Despite this historical and archeological evidence, the international scientific establishment continued to ignore Myanmar’s ceramic traditions and histories of East Asian and Southeast Asian ceramics continued to leave Myanmar’s contributions a ceramic blank page. The situation changed in 1984 after what is known as Green-and-White ceramic ware was found during an illegal excavation near the Thai town of Mae Sot, which is on the border with Myanmar. Chemical analysis revealed that the Green-and-White ware from Mae Sot used tin white and tin green glazes, which had previously been unknown in Southeast Asia. The question of whether the Green-and-White ware originated in Thailand or Myanmar was settled in favour of Myanmar because the clay, the glaze and the shape and style of the Mae Sot finds differ entirely from any known Thai ceramic ware. Chemical analysis also revealed that the lead isotope ratios of the glaze used in the white-glazed ceramic ware with green decorations agree with those of lead ores from Myanmar and those of the glaze from Buddhist temples at Bago and Bagan. The isotope ratios of the Thai lead deposits do not match those of the lead glaze on the Green-and-White ceramic wares. Thus Myanmar lead ore seems to have been used for the glaze and experts have suggested that the white-glazed ceramic wares with green decoration was produced somewhere in Myanmar. Gakuji Hasabe of the Machida City Museum in Japan states: "From these studies, it is nearly certain that Green-and-White ware and plain white and green wares are from Myanmar, but their kiln sites remain to be discovered. Once such a kiln is excavated, the date of production, stylistic evolution, total output, and purpose of Green-and-White ware will be revealed." This absence of kiln sites for Green-and-White ware remained the last stumbling block for final acceptance of a Myanmar origin of such glazed ceramic ware. This led to a concerted effort by the Archeology Department of the Myanmar Ministry of Culture and the Myanmar Ceramic Society to locate kiln-sites that show indications of having produced glazed ceramic ware in the form of manufacturing aids and tools such as supports, shards and broken pieces of ceramic ware. The search was orchestrated by the current president of the Myanmar Ceramic Society, Dr Myo Thant Tyn (who holds a PhD in chemical engineering from Britain) and is recounted in a report published in Orientations magazine titled Ancient Celadon in Myanmar: A New Ceramics Discovery (Vol. 32, No. 4). Hundreds of possible ancient kiln sites for the production of glazed ceramic ware have so far been located.  The kilns are concentrated in several areas, including at Lagumbyee, an old Pyu city on the Yangon-Bago Highway, where more than 100 ancient kilns were discovered; at Twante, about 20 miles southwest of Yangon where hundreds of kiln sites have been located; at Myaung Mya Old City, the third largest kiln site in Myanmar; at Nga-Pu-Taw (some 16 miles southwest of Myaung Mya Old City) where Don Hein and Dr Myo Thant Tyn discovered seven sites; at Bagan; at Sagaing; at Don-za-yit Myo Haung on the east bank of the Sittaung River; at Innwa (Ava) where Don Hein found three up-draft kilns and one old kiln site; and at Mrauk-U where Don Hein also found ground cross-draft kilns near Shwe Kya Thein monastery. Except at two sites, one at Bagan and the other at Lagunbyee, excavations have not yet been carried out. With the quickening of interest in traditional Myanmar ceramics that has been aroused by the latest research on Green-and-White ware by foreign scholars coupled with the finding of ancient ceramic kiln sites by Tyn, Hein and others, the field is wide open for excavations by international scholars with adequate funding and state of the art archeological excavation techniques. The prospects are bright and call for an optimistic outlook, a view shared by many international academics including Frazer-Lu, who wrote in 1994 that "there is an urgent need for archaeologists and ceramic historians to investigate thoroughly the activities of all known, both past and present, to gauge the scope and sequence of Myanmar’s unique ceramic traditions, and to assess their role in the history of the region". As Mr Gakuji Hasabe has aptly said: "I hope that people will discover this unknown realm of Myanmar ceramic ware and enjoy its beauty to the utmost."
(N.B. The author would like to express his sincere thanks to Dr. Myo Thant Tyn, chairman of the Myanmar Ceramics Society
, for his help with documentation and the more technical aspects of this article.)